5
3

Hi,

MSG is a part of lifestyle here in Asia, but I've read that it's not healthy especially if consumed in long term.

I'm trying to substitute it with more natural ingredients like salt and sugar. However, I can't seem to get it exactly right. The food usually ends up really sweet or salty. Am I missing some secret ingredient in the mix? If yes, what is it/are they?

Is there another way to substitute MSG without using sugar and salt at all?

Thank you,

Nadia

asked 27 Nov '09, 10:50

Nadia's gravatar image

Nadia
61122
accept rate: 0%

edited 04 Dec '09, 17:38

Kris's gravatar image

Kris ♦♦
1.1k5713


MSG is a flavor enhancer. This flavor is known as umami or savoriness and is caused by the carboxylate ion in monosodium glutamate(MSG). Anything with glutamate(one of the amino acids) or glutamate derivatives(id MSG) will have this savory taste.

Glutamate is found in any protein rich food(meat, cheese, seafood, nuts, etc)

Salt/sugar as a substitute does not have any of savory flavor and therefore will not work as a substitute.

Fish sauce is the best direct substitute. You can also use Worcestershire sauce or soy sauce if you want to add a more flavor to the dish.

link

answered 30 Nov '09, 20:08

Kris's gravatar image

Kris ♦♦
1.1k5713
accept rate: 25%

Mushroom stock or ground mushrooms will do the job, and is usually what i will use. Alternately, roasted tomato paste, miso paste or roasted bone marrow

link

answered 03 Dec '09, 21:41

Heavysteve's gravatar image

Heavysteve
712
accept rate: 0%

In Mediterranean cultures, the staple source of glutamine is tomatoes / tomato sauce and caramelized onions, sometimes with mushrooms. In China, it is soy sauce. In Japan, it is seaweed. All of these foods are rich in glutamine.

link

answered 06 Dec '09, 05:17

Julius's gravatar image

Julius
311
accept rate: 0%

You might not realize this but MSG stands for monosodium glutamate. This simply means that it is consisted of one sodium (Na+ cation) and one glutamate (an amino acid anion). MSG is an ionic compounds, so once it enters your body, it essentially dissociates into its parts mentioned above.

What is sodium? It is essential for the maintenance of ionic concentrations in your body (more specifically the water contents in your cells due to osmosis). It is also important in generating the electric potential in your nerve cells. Of course in the current day and age, sodium is pretty much found in anything.

What is glutamate? Glutamate is an amino acid, meaning it is the basis of many of the proteins in your body. It is perfectly "natural"; there is really nothing "artificial" about it. All the substitutes above contains glutamic acid, which is basically a MSG molecule with H+ replacing Na+ as the cation. It is broken down in the body in the exact same way as MSG; both results in free glutamate ions.

tl;dr version 1) There is nothing "not natural" about MSG 2) Every food containing glumatic acid naturally is essentially chemically equivalent to MSG. 3) There is no scientific literature associating MSG consumption with increased health risks. All the claims of dizziness and uneasiness after MSG consumption has no statistical basis whatsoever in a double blind placebo experiment. 4) There are way worse things (with serious health consequences) that we consume on a daily basis; nevertheless, people still consume them. 5) Just stop worrying, enjoy your food.

link

answered 06 Dec '09, 17:56

Jerryparid's gravatar image

Jerryparid
311
accept rate: 0%

Soy sauce is a staple of many of my meals for this exact reason.

link

answered 04 Dec '09, 02:17

soundasleepful's gravatar image

soundasleepful
211
accept rate: 0%

The umami argument is bogus. It is used by vested interests and those easily influenced by those selling MSG as good. What MSG does is to make your tongue swell and thereby increase the taste bud surface area. There are better chemicals. If you eat hot spiced food you can double the heat by adding raw lime juice. A lot of Spanish people do this... The other problem with MSG is the added sodium. Monopotassium glutamate (MPG) would be better in this case.

link

answered 22 Nov '13, 20:36

Garush's gravatar image

Garush
1
accept rate: 0%

Very Nice post. Thanks for the sharing. Further details you can also click the link read more

link

answered 17 hours ago

rosewilliam's gravatar image

rosewilliam
1
accept rate: 0%

-1

comment number 3 is a fallacy.

However i will agree that MSG occurs naturally, but only in SMALL AMOUNTS. MSG has countless PROVEN harmful effects. MSG in packs are considered large amounts even if you put only one particle, the small amount that i'm talking about here is the naturally occuring amount already present in your food. Meaning any additional MSG is already a BIG AMOUNT!

So don't use it. MSG is just used by individuals who lack culinary skills.

link

answered 15 Mar '10, 02:23

yasser's gravatar image

yasser
1
accept rate: 0%

Glutamic Acid occurs in high amounts in many different types of food. I agree that adding purified MSG is not necessary, but Glutamic Acid does occur in relatively large amounts in food. Here are some examples of food that is high in glutamic acid: http://www.nutritiondata.com/foods-000093000000000000000.html

(15 Mar '10, 16:07) Kris ♦♦
Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "Title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "Title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×49
×21
×9
×4

Asked: 27 Nov '09, 10:50

Seen: 29,393 times

Last updated: 17 hours ago

Part of the Recipe Puppy network: Recipe Puppy - Cook Thing - Food Guts - Recipe Labs

©2011 RecipeLabs